Winner Of Last Night: SubMercer. Keifer Sutherland Breaks Jack McCollough's Nose!

by Rachelle Hruska · May 5, 2009

[Jack McCollough, Mary-Kate Olsen, Lazaro Hernandez]

UPDATE: They were all at the Rodarte after party with Milla Jovovich, Jessica Szohr, Jessica Stam, Coco Rocha, and both Olsens.

EXCLUSIVE STORY: Last night, the biggest event of the NYC social calendar, the MET Ball, took place.  This also means that it was one of the biggest nights for our city's nightlife.  Your relevance as a hot spot could be validated within minutes of an Olsen's stilettos gracing your floors.  So, where did everyone go to party? Well we know that some people were at Bungalow 8, like Mary-Kate Olsen, but the REAL talk of the town belongs to a certain fight that broke out at SubMercer. Apparently that's where Kiefer Sutherland HEAD BUTTED Jack McCollough so hard that he BROKE the designer's nose!  Details below...

While guests like Mary-Kate Olsen, (who hit up more than one party of course), and Kirsten Dunst looked on, the actor apparently was upset over Brooke Shields. The winner? SubMercer by a landslide.  Jack, one half of Proenza Schouler, is reportedly still in the hospital!

We have received several confirmations that Sutherland actually used a headbutting technique on the designer! Yikes!