You are sooo “American”

Sep 11, 2007 11:38 AM

iwantyou.png

What the heck is it with people (Europeans/Latins) saying "I love America, but hate Americans". I'm not talking about a snobbery based on a disagreement with Bush's foreign policy, but rather a more general position towards our culture and people. A widely and closely held prejudice that "Americans" are so...well, "American". What does this mean? It means we are unsophisticated, myopic, not well traveled, we don't know how to have fun, and we don't sit around at outdoor cafes all day drinking vino tinto and "smoking fags".

So can this really be true? Well in order to digest these criticisms, you have to recognize that this is a typical strawman argument. See our critics have a very narrow definition of sophistication, which is limited to:

a) being a polyglot
b) having a sexy exotic accent
c) having a large number of stamps on your passport of countries you have visited

Based on this definition, most Americans fail miserably, and clearly don't pass as being "sophisticated". But therein lies the fallacy of this argument. Sophistication is not simply restricted to the imposed constraints of a few jet-setting euros. Rather, Sophistication embodies a multitude of criterium. For example, you will NEVER hear a critic say that Americans are not educated. Why, because Americans on a whole posses a massive amount of education and higher-level degrees. And our educational institutions attract our very critics in droves. No, you won't hear anyone say that Americans aren't intellectually sophisticated, because it is simply not defensible.

So, critics are forced to focus on the more superficial "shortcomings" of Americans. The obvious ones. The ones that they can easily sell to another undiscerning individual who will eat it up. And if you challenge the stamp they have placed on the word "sophistication", they are likely to fire back with the loose adjective "worldly". "Yea, well Americans just aren't worldly". What does this mean? We aren't of this world, we don't live on planet earth? Oh, wait I get it, it means we aren't well traveled. Well unfortunately, we don't have the luxury of buying a euro rail pass and hitting 5 different closely-packed countries in 5 days.

Would we like to have another language? Of course! But, we simply aren't required to study and be fluent in more than one language (like many other education systems around the world). Perhaps we are victims of our own success, we can function pretty darn well just by knowing English. This doesn't mean we don't respect or appreciate language, its just not as high a priority. And yes, we would love to have sexy accents so Gwyneth Paltrow would think we are better dinner conversationalists, but that just isn't in the cards...

To contact the author of this post, email guestofaguest@gmail.com

joseph

September 11, 2007

7:32pm

This was hilarious. I could not have been nodding my head harder throughout reading.  

Ha Ha Sound

September 11, 2007

8:23pm

Reminds me of the time somebody in London tried to tell me that "Americans have no culture", to which I replied that we invented jazz, gave the world F. Scott Fitzgerald, Ernest Hemingway, William Faulkner, Thelonius Monk, Miles Davis, Yo-Yo Ma, Martin Scorsese, Stan Brakhage and on and on and on and on. I then told her we just import the shitty parts the nobody here wants, like McDonald's and awful NBC sitcoms.  

guestofaguest

September 11, 2007

9:15pm

@ha ha yes and Warren Buffett, Walt Disney (hehee), Johnny Cash, and the majority of the television and cinema they watch. We love america, but most of all because it is where NYC is located and we heart nyc  

xadness

September 12, 2007

7:46pm

This one cracks me up... there's a 'deeper/ darker' undertone to it ... would you care to talk about it?? :) hehehe... just kidding, well uh... not really.... anyway, great post!  

Don't worry

October 3, 2007

11:51pm

Well not learning another language just because it is not required....indeed does not make you a worldly person (Definitions of worldly on the Web: * characteristic of or devoted to the temporal world; "worldly goods and advancement"* blase: very sophisticated especially because of surfeit; versed in the ways of the world) Your post is rather narrow itself...I do agree the people that believe sophistication is claimed based on your accent is also pretty narrow and knows nothing about sophistication.  

Nesh

March 19, 2008

4:53pm

This is an old post but my favourite so far. Good writing. it is funny and so true ;)  

Anna

October 12, 2008

6:07pm

Goodness! I know a man who's been on all seven continents, And he's a totally uncultured hog. As for being a polyglot, How often would I be using these other languages? I am studying Spanish, but as for studying any other European languages it makes no sense to study just for ostentation. I lived in Europe for a number of years. I've learned one thing: We all have the same needs. as for wants? That is ona person by person basis. I totally agree that it makes no sense to hate anyone based on generalities. I am an American. But I was born a human being.  

julie

August 5, 2010

11:20pm

I think you didn't understood what people don't like about Americans. The problem is that lot of them are self centred, I mean they really don't care about other countries, I've meet some that was surprised to know that we have microwaves in Europe, or even some were thinking we don't have electricity yet! they think that nothing important happens outside of their world. Really we don't care if they don't travel that much if at least they respect other countries. Maybe you're educated but most of you can't place really famous countries on a map or named presidents of these places. Also we don't care about other peoples accents and in fact American accent is kind of sexy in my personal opinion. Speaking others langages is a good point, but if you can't nobody will blame you in Europe, cause we know how hard it is, but what we don't like is when Americans expect us to speak fluent English outside of America and they are very disdainful if not. The truth is that most European speak english and will do if needed, but we don't like when you think we MUST absolutely speak english. In Germany they speak german, in France they speak french etc YOU have to adapt it's not the country you're visiting who have to adapt to you, and if you find peoples speaking your langage there, you have to be greatful, not feeling like it's normal, everybody is making efforts to understand each others, so you have to. If americans have bad images outside the US it's only because of these kind of things, stop feeling so higher than other countries and we would love you like you deserve, and you deserve it actually ! we're all watching your movies, listening your music etc, so I think it's really sad that we're playing that game "you don't like me so I don't like you, but you started first, so you're the one to blame..." and blablabla. About the "you don't know how to have fun"thing, I don't get that point, cause nobody actually think that, we do think that Americans know how to enjoy life, maybe just that they spend too much of their time at their job, but it is only your matter, so that doesn't count. To finish you think that nobody will complain about Americans not being educated, but it is wrong in fact lot of people here think there's only stupid alcoholic rednecks in your country, for this you have to blame TV shows that came from US that we get showed. Luckily most peoples here understand that it is kind of stereotypes, and that not all americans love to play with guns and think we must kill illegal mexican immigrants.  

GUEST COMMENT
You can comment as a guest here.
REGISTER
You can register for an account here.
LOGIN