Has There Secretly Been An In-N-Out In Manhattan For The Past Year?

Aug 4, 2010 11:07 AM

This past April Fool's Day, when College Humor put "Coming Soon: In-N-Out" signs all over the city, they created a furor. (Yes. A furor.) Learning that this was just a prank was a bitter pill to swallow, but today, we are vindicated. Because you guys, there's secretly been an In-N-Out in Manhattan this whole time!-

Take a look at the picture at left, which we took last night. That looks exactly, EXACTLY, like the inside of an In-N-Out burger, doesn't it?

Turns out, there's an In-N-Out Burger on Park Avenue South and 23rd Street. It's just in disguise, as "Fresh & Fast."

IT IS THE SAME RESTAURANT.

Do you need us to prove it? WE CAN PROVE IT.

The Name

In And Out? As in, you're in and you're out and it's fast?

Fresh And Fast? As in, it's fresh and it's fast?

The Logo

Inverse logos in the same color schemes??

The Menu

It's the SAME MENU! Down to the font, the logo in the middle, and the three flavors of milkshake!

The Inside Of The Store

Red and white tile?

The Uniforms

White polo shirts with cheesy hats?

The Burgers

Simple American Burger on a potato bun.

The Religious Proverbs On The Cups:

Missing from Fresh-N-Fast. But come on. It's New York!

Verdict: These two chains are eerily similar, and Fresh-N-Fast is cheaper and faster than Shake Shack.

The owner of the mysterious chain (their website is "in progress"...) told GrubStreet:

"In terms of the quality and consistence of the product, I would compare us to an In-N-Out."

Next time you're feeling homesick for California, perhaps you can go to Fresh-N-Fast and just...pretend?

[Additional photos via]

To contact the author of this post, email guestofaguest@gmail.com

YUM

August 4, 2010

3:54pm

BUT is there secret sauce?! It even has the same 1,2,3 meal deals, amazingggg. Personally, I'm glad to see the lack of biblical inscription. LAME AS HELL, IN-N-OUT.  

thisresa

August 4, 2010

4:01pm

I just went to Fresh-N-Fast last week. It's a pretty solid burger when the Shake Shack line is too long (always), but their fries kind of suck.  

tellinthetruth

August 4, 2010

5:51pm

what we need here in NYC is Umami Burger! not a clone of an overrated mediocrity. fwiw, a friend once launched a Fat Burger in that same neighborhood years ago. A complete failure.  

justsayin

August 4, 2010

5:59pm

recently did take out at the Westside shack. Long wait. Cold food. Just like the original. A sense of queasiness followed.  

thanksnowi'mhungry

August 5, 2010

7:20pm

looks like an In-n-Out copy cat that is about to get shut down thanks to this article.  

InNOut Faithful

August 5, 2010

9:38pm

Upon this similar realization a couple months ago, I tried Fresh and Fast. It is decent, but the similarities stop at the color scheme and menu. Plus it has Manhattan prices, not a Double Double for 3 bucks. Buyer beware.  

In-N-Shout

August 5, 2010

9:55pm

Been there. It's delicious, and it's been around a while so this article isn't going to shut it down. Also check out Petey's in Astoria, same similarities and also delicious!  

August 10, 2010

4:26am

doesn't look a think like a real double double and nice prices.. eep, 7.29 for a double?? Give me a break, you wish...  

August 11, 2010

1:32am

Triple the price? Ha, take that suckers!  

Burger lover

August 22, 2010

7:16pm

The chocolate shake was not thick and creamy as in Vegas. It was a lil bit watery. It was ok. Not something I would order often Its a good burger, juicy when you bite into it. It does have a sauce that's goes well with it. In the end, I felt cheated and wanted more burger than I got. The menu looks the same except it's more money to eat meat here than in Vegas. Lol  

GUEST COMMENT
You can comment as a guest here.
REGISTER
You can register for an account here.
LOGIN