Sure, it's small (cozy!), but it's right off of Ditch Plains in Montauk, so if surfing's your bag, or you'd like for it to be, this place's for you. Three bedrooms, outdoor shower, grill... this place sounds like the perfect low-key getaway. Plus, if you do crave nightlife, Surf Lodge's only 15 minutes away!
[Image via Craigslist]