Molly's Cupcakes is every five-year-old's idea of heaven. Actually, it's pretty close to our current idea of heaven too. This build-your-own cupcake shop has everything you need, from incredible icing to a sprinkle bar. Try the brown butter frosting and you'll understand how Molly's earned its place on our list.
Molly's Cupcakes, 228 Bleeker St.
[Photo via @catty_vanhelsin]