New York City's California-cool surf shack serves a menu of refreshing and fun margaritas perfect for Cinco de Mayo. Spicing up the traditional margarita is the Holla Pain Yo! ($12) a combination of Tanteo jalapeño-infused tequila and citrus juices served over the rocks. For people looking for something with less of a kick, they can try the Betty’s Margarita ($12) made with tequila and their secret margarita mix, served on the rocks.