Gotham Grill's Mary Schoenlein Is South Shore's Official "Muffin Mama"

by CLAIRE WILLETT · June 5, 2008

    Gotham GrillFROM:

    On Amagansett’s Main Street, there’s a little white shop with a red door and a sign which proclaims, in flowing letters, “Mary’s Marvelous.” Inside, there’s that pleasant bustle that accompanies beloved neighborhood institutions, and a beyond pleasant array of baked goods and take-away. Intrigued by the alliteration and the crowds attesting to it, we caught up with owner Mary Schoenlein, a former pastry chef at Gotham Bar and Grill and the current muffin mama for what seems to be half of the south shore, to  discuss cookbooks, gardens, and what happens when the muffins run out……