The Top 10 Hottest New York City Bachelors That Page Six Left Off Their List

Feb 9, 2009 4:24 PM

Page Six recently put together their picks for the top 50 Hottest New York City Bachelors, and while we agreed with some of their choices, there were those who were in fact, not bachelors, and others who left us scratching our heads (also there wasn't a single gay man on the list!) We thought of a few they left out who would make excellent dates this Valentine's Day and who belong on the list of Top Hottest Bachelors In New York City.

Paul Johnson-Calderon

This social scenester aka "The King of Bow Ties" gets our list started for his classic style that has yet to falter and because who wouldn't want to replace Jules Kirby as this fashion stud's arm candy?

[PJC GofaG Directory]

Steve Lewis

For our next bachelor, only the youthful dames need apply. Our favorite king of the nightlife and master of charm, Steve Lewis, likes them young because in case you didn't know, "you can buy them a gift for 300 bucks, and they think you're P. Diddy".

[All Steve Lewis Posts]

See our other picks for New York's Hottest Bachelor's below...-

Nick Cohen

Our favorite bare chested DJ and sneaker pimp makes the list for his multi-tasking capabilities. Being able to keep a party going with his DJ sets and designing fresh shoes while simultaneously winning every girl's heart with his good looks makes him a keeper

[All Nick Cohen Posts]

-

David Foote

This talented artist strays to the left, the right, then back to the left again with his ever changing, flawless style and has been on the prowl for a gem who appreciates eye liner, head bands, tight flannels, and navajo belts as much as he does.  [All David Foote Posts]

Jack Bryan

If you match his taste in film including The Big Lebowski, Requiem for a Dream, Little Big Man, Rushmore, Straw Dogs, and Bad Santa in your list of favorite movies then screenwriter and “The Young and the Guest List” columnist, Jack Bryan is the dude for you.

[All Jack Brian Posts]

-

Nevan Donahue

Next up, is new reality TV show star and New York City bad boy Mr. Donahue. He might have a shady record with the NYPD but he certainly keeps good company with his bff Brad Leinhardt and cousin Olivia Palermo and scoring a date with this eye candy might just get you a cameo on The City.

[All Nevan Donahue Posts]

Patrick & Liam McMullan

And Everyone's favorite famed-photog Patrick McMullan makes the list next. And of course we can't include Patrick without including his son Liam. [All Liam Posts][All Patrick Posts]

-

Scott Buccheit

And last, but certainly not least, is our very own favorite (and newly single) bachelor Scott Bucheit. Scott is always at the hottest parties and events, often playing host.  If you are in the mood to hobnob with socialites and celebs, Scott is your guy.

[All Scott Buccheit Posts]

-

-

To contact the author of this post, email guestofaguest@gmail.com

February 9, 2009

10:08pm

paul johnson calderon YES. that was such a mistake. hes gorgeous. scott is badass everyone else.... eh dont really care. not attractive  

j

February 9, 2009

10:15pm

common...a few are really off here. drug charges, stoners, bears, back hair? pulleeze theyre cool & fun guys, but hottest bachelors..wrong list  

girlygirl

February 9, 2009

10:18pm

paul YES. hes gorgeous and stylish. obvi mistake. scotts adorable. thumbs down to the rest  

Fifth Ave

February 10, 2009

12:19am

you people are delusional. this is disgusting. who? who? and whoer?  

Vile Baby

February 10, 2009

12:40am

it's lists like these that make me wonder what new york has become(or hopefully for all our sakes becoming as in YET to become). i thought LA was the place for self-promoting vapid morons with zero skills and creativity. and i thought women the typical standard bearers for such worthless self-promotion (sorry ladies). this is an insult to new york, new yorkers, and the men and women foolish enough to fall for this list of charlatans. do any of these guys actually do anything? aside from wishing they were girls?  

Mary Rambin

February 10, 2009

12:56am

As much as I love Liam, Scott, and Paul, surely there are some decent men that are of age and not gay? Although come to think about it, I think I would prefer my next boyfriend to be gay. At least then I'll know what I'm getting myself into.  

partypants

February 10, 2009

1:39am

Testify, sistah mary. At least a gay man knows better than to flounce about in my jeans like a hipstertard.  

thumbelina

February 10, 2009

6:53am

LOL self-promoting "socialites" who go to parties to "self promote" because, well, they have nothing better to do, or nothing else going on for themselves. None of these guys are real dating material. nevan is a tard and gets into trouble for dumb stuff...his story is too long to get into..and his "role" on the city is just embarassing. Olivia doesnt have many other friends, but Nevan? pass! Scott is a nice guy so I have nothing to say about him:) Patrick is well, older, and gay...but a very nice guy. A lot of people wouldnt be "socialites" without him. Both good and bad..good when the "socialte" has something to say, but they rarely ever do. So his past stuff with Warhol etc is admirable, but hes just a photographer, and I dont like people that spread self-absorption like wild-fire. Steve is nice, but can be a real creep too. past his prime if he ever had one. Nick is DJ. not a Mark Ronson..just a punk. Paul gets props for his style...i would have included him:) Liam seems like everything he does is through his dad. hes just a stoner with some whatever band...and uhhh.. gaining some weight liam? These are all nice guys, but HOTTEST BACHELORS OF NYC!?!?! id LOVE a date with james franco, vito, chase crawford, ed, jamie johnson, david lauren, andre balaz, magnus, bobby kennedy...these guys are all very attractive and successful in their own right. A ton of women would date them. The older guys on the list (ron perelman etc) are for the older ladies..and, for that matter, its hard to knock down a billionaire, esp when he was married to Ellen Barkin. So these guys you "nominated" weren't forgotten by Page Six. They didnt include them because they didnt deserve to be on the list. (a big ouch I guess bc their names, once in a great while, do slip into to page six when nothing much is going on.. and one of these guys writes for it) i think we would have all been a lot more confused and upset about the ranking if they were on the list in the first place  

jossip

February 10, 2009

7:03am

really..page six "forgot" these guys? out of the 50 that made it? nope. i dont think so. great comments. i love reading the truth once in awhile. i heart ed, chase, andre, james franco, and david lauren. all YUM xoxo  

straightfemale

February 10, 2009

7:33am

you guys are kinda mean. they are all nice guys, but these bachelors are the guys that need to be nice guys. likeable? yes. fun? yes yes. Lust? no no no no no. successful new york women, whatever age they may be, that are beautiful and have a lot going for them would not settle for these bachelors. doesnt make sense but these guys are nice guys. they werent on the list anyway so best not to pick on em  

the city

February 10, 2009

7:39am

HAHA Scoring a date with Nevan on The City?? Wow I can't even imagine. That would be tragic. Humiliating  

Anonymous

February 10, 2009

4:07pm

Liam McMullan is still my favorite. Check out his pictures here: LolaCheck out his pictures here:  

LMAO

February 10, 2009

7:13pm

re: Fifth Avenue Do you do nothing but make negative comments on GOG. I love how every single comment you make is how this person or that person is a nobody, yet you take the time to read each article AND then feel a need to comment. The worst part is that your comments are neither insightful nor funny. If you're going to say something negative at least be witty about it. But that seems beyond your meager capabilities. So why not just shut the fuck up?  

jem

February 10, 2009

8:16pm

Nevan is a great guy from what i know and his bff brad leinhardt is a really nice guy. he keeps good company. dont care for olivia so much however.  

February 10, 2009

8:23pm

re:everyone These comments are awful. Although this site seems to serve as a public forum of sorts(and people do have the right to express their opinion) these comments are disrespectful to the individuals mentioned. Whatever conception these commentors have of these individuals is obviously based on gossip. If these commentors knew some of these guys on a more personal level, they would understand why these guys are liked and loved by so many people. Negative comments that seem to be based on a shallow understanding of their character or a superficial judgement of how they look/are portrayed makes me sick and further indicates how how far removed these commentors are from what these people are like in real life. All of these guys are hot in their own way and seem to be doing a lot more constructive things for themselves than trashing people they dont know on some silly website.  

partypants

February 10, 2009

8:56pm

Gee, silly me. I was under the impression this was a gossip website. Certainly I will henceforth confine my comments to quotes from Rabelais and pondering the greater purpose of our existence.  

partypants

February 10, 2009

8:56pm

ps Anonymous is fat.  

Vile Baby

February 11, 2009

7:18pm

re: anonymous news flash: all press is good press. safe to assume such self-promoting gents as these are aware of that. "negative comments that seem to be based on a shallow understanding of their character"...don't they groom themselves to be characters, publicity seeking, self-cultivated, CHARACTERS. i would, what better way to make more money. i was under the impression that's the way the pr machine rolls. sure, they may be hot in their own way, they may be lovely to interact with personally, sure they may do "constructive" things, I think. but that's an opinion, yours Anonymous, at least really concede that others are entitled to their's before leaping on a morally superior pedestal and flashing us with your weak and transparently hideous defensive argument. this isn't a personal blog, it's public. public interpretations of people and then the publics reactions. get over it. put yourself in the public eye and expect the public's reaction. ohhhh...the vile babies....  

Vile Baby

February 11, 2009

7:18pm

ps-partypants is hot  

CHRISTOPHER CONFESSORE

February 11, 2009

7:44pm

PP is a bachelorette, I believe, but maybe we can do an article in that vein too.  

partypants

February 11, 2009

7:48pm

I think something about the eligible bachelorettes would be fun if I didn't already know it will just be the same 6-10 women already mentioned on here constantly. Meh, might be fun anyway though. And I thank for the compliment, Vile Baby, but I'm far from attractive (fat, middle aged, terrible skin, balding.)  

hahaha

February 11, 2009

8:42pm

these comments are a riot you guys are right...eligible bachelorettes would probably include some of the ugliest women we are expected to put up with and pretend are pretty, like Jules Kirby devorah rose,charlotte ronson, kerry cassidy,briana swanson. those top my list but the list goes on so much major fug all over the place. they are difficult to look at. Byrdie, olivia, amanda and lauren are all very pretty. Lydia is a pretty girl too but not respected in the modeling world. they think she is a joke. so to get back on subject this GOG nomination list is an insult to women everywhere. These guys have accomplished nothing besides having there picture taken and they dont have successful real jobs. It would be more embarrassing then amazing to date one...these guys dont come from the culture or class or accomplishments of the pagesix ones, and none of them are attractive (besides pjc) so pass on the stoners, flabby bodies, back hair, getting into trouble for stupid reasons, men past their prime. GOG get some new attractive guys please!!! this site needs it props go out to party pants and vile baby 4 keepin it real---  

partypants

February 11, 2009

9:18pm

hahaha, that's what I meant to say, but you explained it better. It would pretty much be the same women we see all the time on the site already...Julia Allison, Jules Kirby blah blah blah. How about tossing Rachelle on the list? Emily Brill? At least some girls we don't hear about all the time already just to mix it up.  

CHRISTOPHER CONFESSORE

February 11, 2009

9:30pm

Maybe some women in Tech or Business? no, we'd skip Ivanka, I mean really in business, or writers? They exist, we know them.  

partypants

February 11, 2009

11:48pm

That would be fun. Maybe top five tech bachelors, and then writers, etc etc sounds interesting...  

Flames

February 13, 2009

7:01am

I want to hear about PJC at Dfield WITH Brill... gimme that inside noise...  

GUEST COMMENT
You can comment as a guest here.
REGISTER
You can register for an account here.
LOGIN