The Crow's Nest Inn and Restaurant
Gwyneth loved The Crow's Nest so much, she included them on her list twice; once for the hotel and once for the food! She's a fan of the hotel because "each room is decorated with a rustic and nautical nod to its surroundings – both homey and beachy at the same time," but she recommends you get to the restaurant early if you want to snag a table at the restaurant where "the menu is short [but] well edited and the seafood is excellent as is the atmosphere."
The Crow's Nest Inn and Restaurant
4 Old West Lake Dr, Montauk