The Garret
The Garret now has three locations across the city, but we'll always favor the OG location in the West Village. The only hint you have to finding it is a pink neon sign reading "SOUL" in an upstairs window above the Five Guys. Go inside and up the stairs and boom - a very cool cocktail bar, which, incidentally, also boasts a skylight.
The Garret West, 296 Bleecker St.
[Photo via @thealmas3000]