Waverly Inn
There is basically nothing wrong with Waverly Inn. It's quiet, it's pleasant, it's cool. Really, my only complaint would be that they don't list their menu on their site so you can peruse it ahead of time.
Lucky for you, here's the menu link they're directing you to look at once you've sat down at your table. Peruse away!
Waverly Inn, 16 Bank Street
[Photo via @westvillagetimes]