Queequeg's
Queequeg's is perfect for a night you don't have a reservation. With both indoor and outdoor seating, the restaurant is small but the wait is never too long. There are a few whale carvings but the Moby-Dick allusion does not go overboard. Order the clam chowder and the short rib and run it off on the Cliff bike path in the morning. Afterwards you can go to the bar at Town (adjacent to Queequeg's) and sip Triple Eight blueberry vodka.
Queequeg's, 3527, 6 Oak St, Nantucket, MA
[Photo via @queequegsnantucket]