Pi Pizzeria
Pi begins seating at 5:30 PM. An integral part of the dinner experience is getting to their front stoop at 4:45 and befriending the other freaks who ended their beach day early for thin crust. Don't do carry out - the crust is so thin that it gets soggy fast. Hint: order as soon as you're seated. Get the clam pizza, calamari, and chicken parmesan. When you leave it will still be light and the line will be even longer.
Pi Pizzeria, 11 W Creek Rd, Nantucket, MA
[Photo via @georgantas.design]