Amor y Amargo
This little East Village spot is hard to find but worth looking for. Their whole motto is "I love Bitters" so you know you are going to drink an A+ Old Fashioned in this place. Every bartender at Amor y Amargo knows a lot about cocktails and loves to suggest drinks according to the customers' preferences. We really recommend trying their Old Fashioned (duh!) but anything will be just as good.
Amor y Amargo, 443 E. 6th St.
[Photo via @marinaherbst]