Parm
To enjoy a different Italian old-school vibe, in a far more casual setting, go to Parm. As its name would suggest, Parm's menu does in fact have many a parm option, as well as other big hits like their baked ziti, saratoga club, and, surprisingly enough, buffalo cucumbers. Bottom line, anything you get here is going to be A) terrible for you, B) crazy good, and C) a lot of food. Most importantly, if you allow yourself to leave without ordering the ice cream cake, there's probably little hope for you as a person.
Parm, 248 Mulberry Street
[Photo via @parmny]