Surf Lodge
Most Unique. I know this was usually given to the random emo/goth kid or like the really fat girl who suddenly got hot senior year, but I mean this in a sincere way. Surf Lodge is most definitely the most unique places in all of the Hamptons. On the weekends Surf Lodge definitely becomes so crazy that it is club-esque, in a casual, Montauk fashion. The food is amazing and the crowd is always fun. There was nothing else like it in Montauk, it's definitely a more respectable option than the Memory. It is definitely a venue that will stick with you forever.