Johnny's Bar
We know what you're thinking - a cheap bar in the West Village is just too good to be true. Johnny's is perfect in all it's quaintness, with just the bare necessities (jukebox, strong drinks, good company) to ensure you have a great time. They also offer a variety of unique shots (depending on the day) AND they take credit cards (which is a pretty big plus for a dive bar).
Johnny's Bar, 90 Greenwich Avenue, 212-741-5279
[Photo via @alden_s]