If you’re anything like us, you’ve probably been struggling over how to add fall’s new shows into your already-packed TV schedule. To help you tackle this daunting task, we’ve done a little of the leg work and found out which shows are worth your time. Click through for our list of the 6 shows on your existing schedule that have jumped the shark – and the new (or improved) shows you should swap them out for.

[Photos via, via, via]